3 things the iPad should do
February 5th, 2010 – by MattWe’ve had some great internal discussions about the iPad here at Intuit. In the Innovation Lab – (aka iLab – I wonder how long we’ll get to keep calling ourselves that?) – we started wondering about “always connected small portable devices” back in 2003 during contractor visits. Even then, a few of them had laptops and printers in their trucks so that they could deliver estimates and invoices on the spot.
I like my gadgets – I had a digital voice recorder when they first came out, one of the first Palm phones, even a “luggable” computer – about 30 pounds – with a 5″ Hercules monitor. THAT takes me back…
I don’t have an iPod or an iPhone, though. I was happy with my Palm phones before either existed – and happily synced my music and listened to it through the phone. I’m still happy now with my Droid, having gotten it working the way I want. My main computer is a tablet, small, easy to watch videos and such.
But what about the iPad? You know, I think that we can already check our email, stream movies, read books, browse the web, buy stuff from Amazon. I don’t need another device to do that.
I’ll tell you what I do need, though, and I’d sure like the iPad to do it for me. Video. The home movie experience is currently a pretty bad one. Not watching, or the quality, but the dis-integrated nature of all the video we have lying around.
So here’s the 3 things I want the iPad to do:
1. RIP my DVDs I’m tired of hunting for my DVDs. Is the one I want in the basement game room? Upstairs? Living room? Family room? In one of the myriad DVD cases? I paid for them – I don’t want to RIP rentals – I just want simple access to my collection. Oh, and it needs to RIP the video in high quality as well as preserve the surround sound.
2. Stream videos Since I can get streaming movies via Netflix, or stuff from services like YouTube, I want to quickly and easily select what I want to watch. On my XBOX 360, it’s a pain to find a movie that’s not in my queue. Voice recognition would be good here – sitting in a chair, typing using a remote = not good. Speaking into my remote = good.
3. Record my home movies I have a variety of home movies – VHS, Hi8, HD on SD cards, MP4 from a Flip and even MOV from some phones. Let me easily get those movies onto the device, or better yet, onto my RAID1 2TB NAS device. Simple categories and/or dates is fine.
It’s time for the final vestiges of SneakerNet to be abolished. I hope the iPad, or something like it, will do that.



Todd Hartle | February 5th, 2010 at 5:47 pm
You need a Mac Mini.
Matt
| February 5th, 2010 at 8:36 pm
Correct me if I’m wrong, but a Mac Mini won’t do this either – let me explain.
Yes, I know, it can be configured to do it. So can a PC. I’ve actually done ALL of these things on a PC except the HDMI connection, and that’s doable as well. But it’s all a hack. It’s dis-integrated. I want an integrated solution.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but there’s nothing that will RIP all of my DVD for me (e.g. Mac Ripper) – nothing that’s legal and either free or inexpensive. I have some things on a PC I have dedicated to video handling stuff, including ripper software that is A) Legal to own and use, but B) Illegal to distribute. Any software that can remove copy protection from a DVD, while legal to own, isn’t legal to distribute. So unless you got it before the rulings like I did, you’re out of luck … unless you want to write it yourself.
It’s gonna take a company like Apple with deep pockets to take the issue of personal DVD backups to court and get the Copyright Law and Millennium Digital Rights act reconciled.
Here’s what I have now: old Laptop w/DVD ripper – I use that to get full quality DVDs onto my NAS. XBOX 360 – I can stream from the NAS to my TV with it, including surround sound. ViewPoint Digital Video Converter – that gets my non-digital videos onto an SD card, which I can then transfer to my NAS. I also have S-Video capture hardware, but the ViewPoint is easier – and it doesn’t need to record any higher quality than the original standard TV format.
I also have Netflix on the XBOX 360 – but it’s not a great experience. On another TV, I have a connected PC that can stream Netflix – that’s actually a better experience.
I want a single Plug and Play device that can do all of these things, do them right out of the box, and super simple.
And I want all this with a wireless remote control that is voice command capable.
Wouldn’t be too hard to prototype – but impossible to take to market, at least until the laws are settled.
- Matt H
Todd Hartle | February 13th, 2010 at 1:26 pm
OWC Posts Mac mini Media Center Guide
http://www.123macmini.com/news/story/1446.html
leave a comment